McLaren Park History
McLaren Park is the second largest San Francisco city park. Yet it remains a secret to most San Franciscans, in a part of the city most have yet to visit. The park’s remoteness and location on a hilltop allows McLaren to retain an unusual character for such a built up city; much of the park feels ‘wild’.
The park was dedicated in 1927 after a city-wide campaign to create it. The first wave of improvements date back to the 1930’s, when the WPA era built trails and planted trees. In the 1950’s the park’s boundaries were finalized, incorporating what was agricultural land. In the 1970’s, the Rec and Park department built a BMX race track in the park and ran races every year. The paved path system you see at McLaren today was added in the 1980s to provide several loop options through the park and link it to the neighborhood. In the 1990’s, the movement to preserve rare Natural Resource Area city-wide ramped up and many areas in McLaren park were identified for their value. In the late 2000’s into the early 2010’s, the Philosopher’s Way was added to the park, using both existing trails (both historic and user-created) and building new ones. The Philosopher’s Way was designed as both a trail and an art project, providing a route to several spots designed as a location to pause for thought or to take in a particular view, and often includes historical information about the neighborhood or nature in that spot. In addition, all of the new segments were designed and built to best practice multi-use standards, many with the assistance of SF Urban Riders.
SFUR has also brought several community events to McLaren Park, hosting Take A Kid Mountain Biking Day from 2009-2011 and the SF Mountain Bike Festival/McLaren Short Track Challenge in 2013-2014. In addition, the new McLaren Bike Park project was initiated by SFUR in 2011, then continued by the McLaren Bike Park Founders shortly after, and is about to open this month (October 2017).
We have continued to do volunteer projects in McLaren park, and plan to continue that in the future.
McLaren Visioning Plan – Trails Component
Currently, the Recreation and Park Department is going through another planning process: The McLaren Visioning Plan. The primary goal is to determine how to spend millions of dollars allocated under a 2012 bond, and to set up future projects for future bond.
Trails for hikers and mountain bikers have been a top request in every single survey of the park, including ones taken in 1983, 2004, and 2016. This preference is reflected in the current plan, where trails are a key feature.
The trails plan in the McLaren Visioning Plan has four goals and three main components. The goals include safety, natural character, protecting natural resources, and clarifying circulation. The components consist of a pair of ‘primary’ main loop routes around the park, ‘secondary’ important connections, and ‘tertiary’ additional trails which are used for fun. The plan includes about miles of routes, of which a few are designated for bicycles.
The Future of Riding trails in McLaren
In keeping with the community’s repeated preference in surveys for trails open to biking, SF Urban Riders believes that there needs to be enough riding in the park open to cycling to make it interesting and valuable for multiple types of users. That means enough miles of bike-friendly trails to create several loops, with a significant amount of challenge, closeness to nature, and playfulness. In particular, the Visioning Plan should retain the existing trails which have been built for this purpose, improve them, as well as create a few new bike-friendly trails.
SF Urban Riders believes that the following needs must be met to honor the public’s preference for providing ample trails for riding bicycles:
- Provide multiple options for that cater to the variety of user levels and needs, from young beginners to experts.
- Maintain and improve the existing narrow trails that are open to cyclists, including segments of Philosopher’s Way, the University Switchbacks, and other trails south of Mansell.
- Maintain and improve the existing wider trails in the core of the park (inside the Shelley loop) that get high pedestrian and dog usage.
- Create a sustainable connecting trail near the west edge of the Golf Course to connect the new Bike Park (and Crocker Amazon) with the upper part of the park. This trail should be both open to bikes and optimized for bicycles.
- Provide for park activation by making it easier for events like races. This includes both appropriate trails and ensuring that the non-trails capital projects enable events of all sorts.
- If park usage grows, consider creating additional trails.
We’re happy with much of the current vision plan, as it provides several loops and trails. We believe the priority projects are important to fix ongoing issues. However, there are a few areas of concern.
- There are not enough enough miles of trails with texture, character, and challenge to provide engagement and skill building for mountain bikers.
- 5′ minimum width for all multi-use trails. This is appropriate for certain high use areas, but not the entire park. There are many examples of narrow (less than 4′ wide), safe and successful multi-use trails in San Francisco, throughout the Bay Area, and in urban parks world-wide.
- Excessive trail consolidation. This increases the likelihood for problems, such possible conflicts between user goals and visitors creating their own unsustainable social trails.
Regardless of the issues we’ve outlined, SF Urban Riders is ecstatic to see progress and look forward to continuing to contribute to McLaren Park.
To learn more about the Visioning Plan, visit http://sfrecpark.org/project/mclaren-park-improvements-project-2012-bond/ . For the most recent Trails info, see http://sfrecpark.org/presentation-from-final-mclaren-trails-and-paths-focus-group-workshop/
To see a map we have created based on the park and their information, see the SFUR version of the Visioning Plan map
This plan is now at the Approval stage with the Rec Park commission.
Attend the Rec Park Commission meeting, November 16th to support more and better riding in McLaren Park. 10:00 AM at City Hall room 416.
We are conditionally supportive of the plan: they listened to our need for trails by designating about 3.5 miles of the most important trails in the park for bicycle usage. And it directs the $2 million budget towards some important trail repairs.
However, while it recognizes great existing singletrack, it has some serious flaws which must be addressed before the plan is approved.
The major flaw is that it has a 5′ standard for bicycle use on trails. This is a major step backwards from current policy, and not consistent with the direction other agencies in the area are moving. Most other local agencies use a policy similar to the IMBA recommendation to “Keep trails narrow to reduce the total area of intensive tread disturbance, slow trail users, and minimize vegetation and soil impacts.”.
In addition, the plan proposes decommissioning many important and popular trails, well beyond that needed for sustainability.
Our note of conditional support for the plan can be found at McLaren-Vision-Plan-SFUrbanRiders.pdf